Unable to set up domain on new site after removing it from old site on same account

We’re in the middle of launching a new site on the same Netlify account as the old site. After removing the custom domain from the old site, I tried to add it to the new site and got the following error:

thefair.com or one of its subdomains is already managed by Netlify DNS on another team.

I also updated out DNS to add a TXT record with the host of “verified-for-netlify”, and the value of “wsfec-website.netlify.app” based on info I got from your Ask Netlify chatbot.

Custom domain: www.thefair.com

I need help addressing this ASAP, thanks.
Scott

The domain has been removed from the other account.