Stuck on "Connect to Git provider"

I am trying to import a new git repo from my previously connected Github account. When I click the “New site from Git” button, I am prompted to “Connect to Git provider”. I have previously authorized Netlify to connect to my github account, and it is working for my existing site, but I am unable to proceed to step 2. I have even tried clicking on “Github” on this screen to perhaps RE-authorize it, but it just pops up a window that declares me as “Authorized” (see attached screenshot)

Hey there! Have you checked the basics i.e. tried in a different browser, without any plugins etc, cognito mode and with a cleared cache?