You have an error in the configuration for www.wfshores.com. As noted in the configure external DNS → Configure a subdomain documentation, you are meant to create a CNAME record for www using the value of your Netlify subdomain — windfish.netlify.app in this case — and not with the apex load balancer address (the apex is wfshores.com.)
Do this, ensure the www subdomain and apex are assigned to the site as custom domains then check, and if necessary renew, the SSL certificate.