I am following this help article to set up a subdomain to point at a Netlify app. I have a custom domain set up and using Netlify DNS already (has been set up for years). I created a CNAME record for expense.harvestland.church to point at harvestland-expense.netlify.app , but even after a weekend of waiting when trying to visit expense.harvestland.church I still see a “Not Found” message on the page.
The issue seems to be that you have another DNS set up in front of Netlify (WP Engine, perhaps?). Perhaps try making this CNAME entry at your primary DNS console.
@gregraven I don’t. The registrar is through NameSilo, and the nameservers are pointing at Netlify’s own nameserver addresses. The only other DNS records I have set up are related to GSuite and a couple records for email specific things.