SSL renewal stuck despite valid DNS and successful Let's Encrypt validation

Site: iridescent-cassata-dfda1f

I’m using external DNS through GoDaddy.

Current DNS:

  • A @ → 75.2.60.5
  • CNAME www → iridescent-cassata-dfda1f.netlify.app

My Netlify subdomain works:

https://iridescent-cassata-dfda1f.netlify.app

Netlify still says:

eugenegodfrey.com doesn’t appear to be served by Netlify”

and refuses to renew the SSL certificate.

Diagnostics completed:

  • DNSChecker confirms the A and CNAME records are correct.
  • Let’s Debug reports “All OK!” with no CAA, DNSSEC, IPv6, or HTTP-01 issues.
  • The certificate expired June 7.

Could someone from Netlify please check whether my domain verification or SSL provisioning is stuck on the backend?