SSL renewal failed for howmanyofmes.com – Domain attached, DNS appears correct, but Netlify serves *.netlify.app certificate

Site name:
howmanyofme.netlify.app

Custom domains:
howmanyofmes.com
www.howmanyofmes.com

Issue

My website was working normally until June 7–8, 2026. The Netlify subdomain continues to work, but the custom domain now returns:

NET::ERR_CERT_COMMON_NAME_INVALID

The HTTPS section reports:

howmanyofmes.com doesn’t appear to be served by Netlify”

and Netlify is unable to renew the Let’s Encrypt certificate.

ATTACH SSL/TLS ERROR SCREENSHOT HERE

Troubleshooting completed

• Confirmed the Netlify subdomain is working normally.

• Confirmed both custom domains are attached to the correct site.

• Confirmed DNS is managed through Netlify DNS.

• Verified DNS propagation globally.

• Confirmed the domain resolves to Netlify IP addresses.

• Confirmed www points to the Netlify subdomain.

• Confirmed Netlify DNS nameservers are configured at the registrar.

• Reviewed netlify.toml and _redirects and found nothing that should affect SSL provisioning.

• Removed and re-added the custom domain to force revalidation.

• Waited for Netlify DNS propagation to complete.

Additional observation

A TLS inspection shows the server is presenting Netlify’s default wildcard certificate (*.netlify.app) instead of a certificate for howmanyofmes.com.

The site itself is reachable through the Netlify subdomain, but the custom domain receives NET::ERR_CERT_COMMON_NAME_INVALID.

Could someone from the Netlify team please investigate whether there is a stuck SSL validation state, certificate provisioning issue, stale domain association, or another backend issue preventing certificate renewal?

Thank you.