Custom domain verified but Netlify says "doesn't appear to be served by Netlify"

Hi,

I’m having trouble with a custom domain on Netlify.

Custom domain:
artofwellnessbeing.com

Netlify site:
taupe-dusk-85ebf4.netlify.app

Current DNS records:

A @ 75.2.60.5
A @ 99.83.190.102
CNAME www taupe-dusk-85ebf4.netlify.app

DNS provider:
Squarespace Domains

DNSChecker confirms the records are propagated globally.

The Netlify subdomain works correctly:
taupe-dusk-85ebf4.netlify.app

The custom domain appears in Domain Management, but Netlify shows:

artofwellnessbeing.com doesn’t appear to be served by Netlify”

SSL certificate expired on Apr 22 and cannot be renewed.

I have already:

  • Verified DNS records
  • Removed and re-added the custom domain
  • Waited more than 48 hours
  • Confirmed no duplicate DNS records exist

Could someone help determine why Netlify is unable to verify the domain and renew the SSL certificate?

Thank you.