SSL renewal failing for obakesmansion.com - Netlify DNS propagating for 48+ hours and ACME challenge returns 404

Site name: obakesmansion

Site URL:
obakesmansion.netlify.app

Custom domains:
www.obakesmansion.com (Primary)
obakesmansion.com (Redirect to primary)

Issue:

My Let’s Encrypt certificate renewal is failing with:

SniCertificate::CertificateValidationError:
Unable to verify challenge for obakesmansion.com: 99.83.190.102

Invalid response from:

http://obakesmansion.com/.well-known/acme-challenge/

Response: 404

Current status:

  • Certificate expires June 13, 2026

  • HTTPS currently works

  • Renewal fails every time

DNS configuration:

Registrar:
Squarespace Domains (formerly Google Domains)

Nameservers:
ns-cloud-b1.googledomains.c o m

ns-cloud-b2.googledomains.c o m

ns-cloud-b3.googledomains.com

ns-cloud-b4.googledomains.c o m

DNS Records:

A @ → 75.2.60.5
A @ → 99.83.190.102
CNAME www → obakesmansion.netlify.app

Additional details:

  • Website loads correctly on both domains.

  • DNS resolves correctly globally.

  • Removed duplicate domain alias.

  • Added ACME exception in _redirects.

  • No netlify.toml file.

  • Netlify still shows “Netlify DNS propagating…” after more than 48 hours.

  • Domain page still reports certificate renewal incomplete: missing domains obakesmansion.com.

Could someone please check whether the domain verification or SSL provisioning state is stuck on the Netlify side?