Attempting to get a letsencrypt cert from netlify gives me this error every time. My DNS appears to be set up properly, I’ll post a screenshot of my settings in a reply because my account here is too new to include more than one image in each post.
The first ALIAS record is for n3wy0rk.net.n3wy0rk.net so best remove it. The other two records are correct.
n3wy0rk.net loads with SSL. This means the certificate is issued and this is quite likely a UI bug. Given it is a long weekend for a lot of people Netlify might not address this quickly. As I don’t work for Netlify there is always the chance I’m wrong