External DNS Let's Encrypt renewal failing with NXDOMAIN wildcard error

Hello, my site’s custom domain is supremeglass.net. I manage my records via an external DNS provider. My certificate renewal is currently blocked by an NXDOMAIN error searching for the_acme-challenge.supremeglass.net wildcard TXT record. Could an administrator please remove the wildcard requirement from my account settings and issue a standard Let’s Encrypt certificate just for supremeglass.net and www.supremeglass.net? Thank you!