Can't provision Let's Encrypt SSL certificate – "wifiboxusa.com doesn't appear to be served by Netlify"

PLEASE help us help you by writing a good post!

We’re experiencing a recurring issue with SSL provisioning for our domain wifiboxusa.com.

:white_check_mark: Context:

  • The domain is connected to Netlify.
  • DNS settings are configured correctly with A records pointing to:
    • 75.2.60.5
    • 99.83.190.102
  • Netlify DNS shows a green check :white_check_mark: for the www subdomain.
  • However, the root domain wifiboxusa.com repeatedly returns to “Preparing your domain…” and the SSL certificate cannot be issued.
  • The error remains:

    wifiboxusa.com doesn’t appear to be served by Netlify”

:white_check_mark: Steps already tried:

  • Re-added the custom domain
  • Flushed DNS cache (Google Public DNS)
  • Checked with DNS checker (records are properly propagated)
  • Cleaned old records like amnet/john subdomains
  • Waited over 24 hours multiple times
  • Reverified manually from the dashboard (Retry option is often missing)

Would appreciate your help resolving this issue, or verifying if there’s anything blocking SSL provisioning on your end.

Thanks in advance!

Best regards,

We’ve routed this request to our helpdesk, we’ll follow up via email.